Check it's really a conflict

  1. How many people do you actually need on those days? The answer might be that you can approve both if you cover it differently.
  2. Can someone in another role cover part of it?
  3. Would partial days work, such as one person off Friday and the other off Saturday?
  4. Is either request protected leave? Some leave is protected by law; check before treating it as a choice.

Tie-breakers, in order

A common order. Pick yours, write it down, and apply it the same way every time.
RuleHow it worksWatch for
Who asked firstEarliest dated request winsPeople requesting a year ahead just in case; set a window, such as 3 months
Rotation for peak datesWhoever had the date off last time goes to the backNeeds a record; keep one
ReasonWeddings, funerals, school breaks for parentsHard to judge fairly; use it only for genuine one-off events
SeniorityLongest-serving person winsCan feel unfair to newer staff if it's the only rule
A common order. Pick yours, write it down, and apply it the same way every time.

Telling both people

Approving

Hi Ana, your time off for Friday 26 to Sunday 28 is approved. Enjoy it.

Declining, with an offer

Hi Ben, I'm sorry, I can't approve Friday 26 to Sunday 28 as well: Ana asked first and I need one of you here that weekend. I can give you Saturday 27 if Theo covers your shift, and you're first in line for the next long weekend. Let me know.

Decide within a few days of the request, so people can plan. A request left hanging until the schedule is posted feels like a no without the courtesy of an answer.