Check it's really a conflict
- How many people do you actually need on those days? The answer might be that you can approve both if you cover it differently.
- Can someone in another role cover part of it?
- Would partial days work, such as one person off Friday and the other off Saturday?
- Is either request protected leave? Some leave is protected by law; check before treating it as a choice.
Tie-breakers, in order
| Rule | How it works | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Who asked first | Earliest dated request wins | People requesting a year ahead just in case; set a window, such as 3 months |
| Rotation for peak dates | Whoever had the date off last time goes to the back | Needs a record; keep one |
| Reason | Weddings, funerals, school breaks for parents | Hard to judge fairly; use it only for genuine one-off events |
| Seniority | Longest-serving person wins | Can feel unfair to newer staff if it's the only rule |
Telling both people
Hi Ana, your time off for Friday 26 to Sunday 28 is approved. Enjoy it.
Hi Ben, I'm sorry, I can't approve Friday 26 to Sunday 28 as well: Ana asked first and I need one of you here that weekend. I can give you Saturday 27 if Theo covers your shift, and you're first in line for the next long weekend. Let me know.
Decide within a few days of the request, so people can plan. A request left hanging until the schedule is posted feels like a no without the courtesy of an answer.