Compared
| Compared | Group chat | Scheduling app |
|---|---|---|
| Where the current schedule lives | A photo or file, maybe out of date | One schedule, always current |
| Who sees a change | Everyone, every time | The people on the shift |
| Swaps | Agreed between two people; the manager may not know | Requested in the app; the manager approves |
| Call-outs | A message to everyone at 6 AM | An open shift that eligible coworkers volunteer for |
| Record | Scroll back and hope | Requests and approvals recorded |
| Notifications at night | Every message, to everyone | Only the ones that concern you |
| Cost | Free | Free plans for small teams; paid plans vary |
When the chat is fine
- Quick operational questions: where's the spare key, is the delivery here.
- Very small teams with fixed shifts and almost no changes.
- Social messages that have nothing to do with who works when.
Rules for running both
- The schedule lives in one place. If it's not on the schedule, it didn't happen.
- Swaps and coverage go through the app, never only the chat.
- The chat is for quick questions and news, not for changing shifts.
- Post the rule once, pin it, and point to it when someone forgets.
From Monday, all schedule changes go through the scheduling app: swaps, cover and time off. If it's not in the app, the shift hasn't changed. This chat is for quick questions and news.