Compared

Running shift changes in a group chat and in a scheduling app
ComparedGroup chatScheduling app
Where the current schedule livesA photo or file, maybe out of dateOne schedule, always current
Who sees a changeEveryone, every timeThe people on the shift
SwapsAgreed between two people; the manager may not knowRequested in the app; the manager approves
Call-outsA message to everyone at 6 AMAn open shift that eligible coworkers volunteer for
RecordScroll back and hopeRequests and approvals recorded
Notifications at nightEvery message, to everyoneOnly the ones that concern you
CostFreeFree plans for small teams; paid plans vary
Running shift changes in a group chat and in a scheduling app

When the chat is fine

  • Quick operational questions: where's the spare key, is the delivery here.
  • Very small teams with fixed shifts and almost no changes.
  • Social messages that have nothing to do with who works when.

Rules for running both

  1. The schedule lives in one place. If it's not on the schedule, it didn't happen.
  2. Swaps and coverage go through the app, never only the chat.
  3. The chat is for quick questions and news, not for changing shifts.
  4. Post the rule once, pin it, and point to it when someone forgets.
A message to pin in the group chat

From Monday, all schedule changes go through the scheduling app: swaps, cover and time off. If it's not in the app, the shift hasn't changed. This chat is for quick questions and news.