Compared

Three ways to record hours for a small hourly team
ItemPaper sheetPunch card clockTime clock app
Upfront costNothingThe machine and cardsOften a monthly plan; a tablet for a kiosk
Records the actual timeOnly as writtenYes, stampedYes, to the minute
Missed punchesBlank lines, found at payrollBlank cards, found at payrollFlagged on the day, in most apps
Matched to the scheduleNoNoYes, in apps that also schedule
Adding up hoursBy handBy hand, or the machine totalsAutomatic, including overnight shifts
Buddy punchingEasyEasy with shared cardsHarder with personal PINs or phones
Payroll exportRetypeRetypeExport a file
Works without power or internetYesBattery modelsDepends on the app
Three ways to record hours for a small hourly team

The hidden cost of paper: adding it up

A ten-person team on paper produces about 50 lines a week. At a minute a line to read, total and check, that's close to an hour a week, plus the time spent chasing blank lines. The time spent on scheduling calculator turns that into a yearly figure.

When paper still fits

  • Two or three people with fixed hours.
  • A backup for the day the tablet or internet is down. Keep the clock-in and clock-out sheet printed under the counter.
  • Short-term or event staff for a single day.

When an app pays off

  • More than a handful of people, or shifts that change week to week.
  • Night shifts, split shifts or breaks that make adding up error-prone.
  • Staff at more than one site, where a location check at the punch helps.
  • Payroll that takes you more than half an hour to prepare.

To choose between a shared tablet and staff phones once you've decided on an app, read kiosk vs mobile time clock. The time clock buying checklist has a scorecard for a one-week trial.