Compared
| Item | Paper sheet | Punch card clock | Time clock app |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Nothing | The machine and cards | Often a monthly plan; a tablet for a kiosk |
| Records the actual time | Only as written | Yes, stamped | Yes, to the minute |
| Missed punches | Blank lines, found at payroll | Blank cards, found at payroll | Flagged on the day, in most apps |
| Matched to the schedule | No | No | Yes, in apps that also schedule |
| Adding up hours | By hand | By hand, or the machine totals | Automatic, including overnight shifts |
| Buddy punching | Easy | Easy with shared cards | Harder with personal PINs or phones |
| Payroll export | Retype | Retype | Export a file |
| Works without power or internet | Yes | Battery models | Depends on the app |
The hidden cost of paper: adding it up
A ten-person team on paper produces about 50 lines a week. At a minute a line to read, total and check, that's close to an hour a week, plus the time spent chasing blank lines. The time spent on scheduling calculator turns that into a yearly figure.
When paper still fits
- Two or three people with fixed hours.
- A backup for the day the tablet or internet is down. Keep the clock-in and clock-out sheet printed under the counter.
- Short-term or event staff for a single day.
When an app pays off
- More than a handful of people, or shifts that change week to week.
- Night shifts, split shifts or breaks that make adding up error-prone.
- Staff at more than one site, where a location check at the punch helps.
- Payroll that takes you more than half an hour to prepare.
To choose between a shared tablet and staff phones once you've decided on an app, read kiosk vs mobile time clock. The time clock buying checklist has a scorecard for a one-week trial.