Signs in your records
- Two people clocking in within seconds of each other on the same device, again and again.
- A clock-in recorded on time but the person is seen arriving later, or isn't on the camera, or the register login is later.
- A shared punch card or a sign-in sheet where one handwriting fills in several lines.
- A phone punch from somewhere other than where the shift is, on a clock that records location at the punch.
Practical ways to stop it
| Measure | What it does | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Personal PIN or login, never shared | Ties each punch to one person | PINs can still be shared; say clearly that it's not allowed |
| Time clock in sight of the manager or a camera already there | Makes a borrowed punch visible | Only works when someone is looking |
| Clock in on your own phone | Each person punches for themselves | Needs a smartphone; offer a kiosk for those without one |
| Location check at the punch | Flags a phone punch from outside the site | Doesn't prove who held the phone; tell staff it's on |
| Weekly review of punches against the schedule | Catches patterns early | Takes 15 minutes a week |
If you find it
- Check the records before you raise it: schedule, punches, register logins.
- Talk to both people separately and calmly. Often it starts as a favor for someone running five minutes late.
- Correct the time records to the hours actually worked, with a note.
- Restate the rule, and follow your written policy on what happens next time.
A weekly routine for spotting this and other punch problems is in the weekly attendance review. For choosing between a shared tablet and phones, see kiosk vs mobile time clock.