Rounding: allowed if it's neutral
The federal regulation on rounding, 29 CFR 785.48(b), accepts rounding to the nearest 5 minutes, tenth or quarter of an hour, provided that over a period of time it doesn't result in failing to pay for time actually worked. In practice that means rounding both ways: up as often as down.
| Punch | Rounded to | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| 8:07 | 8:00 | 7 minutes not paid |
| 8:08 | 8:15 | 7 minutes paid extra |
| 4:52 PM | 4:45 PM | 7 minutes not paid |
| 4:53 PM | 5:00 PM | 7 minutes paid extra |
A grace period is not rounding
A grace period, such as 7 minutes, decides whether a clock-in counts as late for attendance. Someone who punches at 9:05 for a 9:00 shift isn't marked late. Their pay still starts at 9:05, or at the rounded time if you round neutrally. Keep the two rules separate in your policy, so nobody thinks being inside the grace period means being paid from 9:00.
Early clock-ins
- If someone clocks in early and starts working, that time is hours worked and must be paid.
- If someone clocks in early but doesn't work, for example sitting in the break room, 29 CFR 785.48(a) says that time need not be counted. The record should show they weren't working.
- The cleaner way is a rule: don't clock in more than a few minutes before your shift unless a manager asks. Then you rarely have to decide after the fact.
Late clock-outs
The same applies at the end. A closer who clocks out 25 minutes late because the close ran over has worked those minutes. If closes run over often, change the shift times; see closing shifts that run over.